CD Coming Due? Compare CDs and MYGAs | Ask Greg About Annuities
CD coming due?

Before you renew, compare it to a MYGA.

A multi-year guaranteed annuity (MYGA) works a lot like a CD: a fixed rate, locked in for a set number of years. The differences, in rates and in taxes, can add up to real money.

CD vs. MYGA at a glance

Bank CDMYGA
RateFixed for the termFixed for the term (often 2 to 10 years)
Taxes on interestTaxed every year, even if you don't touch itTax-deferred until you withdraw it
Backed byFDIC insurance, up to its limitsThe financial strength and claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company
Early accessEarly withdrawal penalty, usually a few months of interestMost allow about 10% a year free; more than that during the term carries a surrender charge
Before age 59½No IRS penaltyGains withdrawn before 59½ may face a 10% IRS penalty
At the end of the termRenew, cash out, or move itRenew, cash out, move it, or turn it into lifetime income

MYGAs fit money you won't need for the length of the term. Money you may need soon belongs somewhere more liquid.

CD vs. MYGA calculator

Enter the rates you've been quoted. The example rates are placeholders, not current offers.

$
%
%

After 5 years, after taxes

CD, taxed each year–
MYGA, taxed at the end–
MYGA before taxes–

Difference

–

Assumes the CD's interest is taxed yearly and reinvested, and the MYGA gain is taxed once, when withdrawn as a lump sum. State taxes not included. For illustration only.

What I'll do for you

  • Pull current MYGA rates from multiple carriers, not just one
  • Check each company's financial strength rating
  • Match the term to when you'll actually need the money
  • Show you the surrender schedule and free-withdrawal terms in plain English
  • Tell you if renewing your CD is the better move

Rates change often. I keep specific rates off this site so they're never out of date. Schedule a call and I'll show you today's numbers for your amount and term.

Have a question about your money?

Bring me the numbers: a CD that's coming due, a 401(k) you're about to roll over, or an illustration someone sent you. I'll give you a straight read on it. The call is free and commits you to nothing.